Keurig Elite vs. Supreme: The Ultimate Comparison Guide for Coffee Lovers

Published on

*This post contains affiliate links. We will earn a commission if you buy after clicking our links

This is our comparison review of the Keurig Elite vs Supreme.

As always, Moderno Coffee aims to bring you the best coffee reviews on the web. So we’ve scoured the forums, sites, and blogs and even spent a few hours reviewing the products ourselves to bring you a thorough comparison of both models.

Overall, our pick is the Keurig K-Supreme.

This premium model brews bold, flavorful coffee that you can customize to your exact preferences. With its metal accents and feature-packed interface, the K-Supreme looks and functions like a high-end, specialty coffee maker.

Check it out here on Amazon.

Keurig K-Elite Single-Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Maker, Brushed Slate, 12 oz. Brew Size

Keurig K-Elite

Keurig® K-Supreme Single Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Maker, MultiStream Technology, Black

Keurig K-Supreme

Performance

4/5

4.5/5

Ease of use

4/5

4/5

Design

3/5

4/5

Features

3/5

5/5

Value for money

3/5

4/5

The ratings above should be everything you need to make a decision.

But if you want more details, take a gander at the rest of the article. We go into a lot more detail in the five categories: Performance, Ease of use, Design, Features, and Value for money.

Speaking of value for money, if you want a more budget-friendly model, check out our Keurig K-Mini review.

But up first… let’s chat about each coffee maker one at a time.

Keurig K-Elite: At a Glance

Keurig K-Elite Single-Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Maker, Brushed Slate, 12 oz. Brew Size

The Keurig K-Elite coffee maker allows you to brew a variety of cup sizes, from 4 ounces up to 12 ounces, plus an iced coffee setting.

You get some useful features like a strong brew option for bolder coffee, a large 60oz removable water reservoir that’s easy to refill one-handed, and an alert system letting you know when the water is running low.

The K-Elite also has adjustable brew temperature controls so you can customize the flavor of your coffee.

A programmable auto-brew function and clock is featured too, which is probably our favorite feature of the K-Elite. It means you don’t have to waste time brewing during those cold, early hours of the morning. Pretty cool!

The removable drip tray accommodates travel mugs and has an 8oz catch basin if you forget to place a cup.

It works with K-cups for mess-free brewing. One minor issue is you need to turn on the coffee maker before selecting your cup size.

Overall, the Keurig K-Elite coffee maker has performed well over several months of use, with great features and adjustable controls.

Keurig K-Supreme: At a Glance

Keurig® K-Supreme Single Serve K-Cup Pod Coffee Maker, MultiStream Technology, Black

The Keurig K-Supreme is a sleek, black single-serve coffee maker that brews 4 cup sizes (6, 8, 10, 12 oz) using K-Cup pods.

It has a large 66 oz removable water reservoir with an integrated water filter so you don’t need to use filtered water.

The K-Supreme has multiple brew settings like strong brew and iced coffee. It heats the water and brews cups in under a minute.

The easy-to-use interface has buttons to choose cup size, power on/off, and settings like strong brew. Just pop in a K-Cup, choose your size, and brew.

The K-Supreme makes hot, delicious coffee, lattes, and other beverages in seconds. Its integrated filter ensures great tasting brews cup after cup. A sleek black design and simple interface makes the K-Supreme easy to use for all your coffee needs.

Comparing the Keurig Elite vs Supreme

Now that we’ve looked at each coffee maker in turn, let’s now check out how they stack up against one another using our five review criteria.

Performance

The K-Supreme edges out the K-Elite when it comes to performance and coffee flavor. In taste tests, the K-Supreme produced a stronger tasting cup of coffee thanks to its multi-stream technology and adjustable strength settings.

But it’s slower to brew a maximum strength cup, taking over 1 minute compared to under 1 minute for the K-Elite.

Winner of Measurement: K-Supreme

Ease of Use

Both models are easy to operate, with simple button controls.

The water reservoirs are removable for easy filling.

The K-Supreme may have a slight edge with its handle for easier carrying while full.

The K-Elite’s reservoir is more awkward to handle with two hands needed.

Winner of Measurement: It’s a tie!

Design

These are both attractively designed coffee makers with a modern look.

The K-Supreme has a stainless steel exterior wrap that gives it a sleeker appearance compared to the plastic and brushed metal on the K-Elite model.

The K-Elite is slightly more compact in size at 16.5 inches tall versus 16.93 inches for the K-Supreme.

Winner of Measurement: It’s a tie!

Features

The K-Supreme offers more customization options with its strength, temperature and preset buttons. It also includes a useful 4 oz brew size. The K-Elite still has handy features like auto on/off and a large LED display but lacks the advanced programming abilities of the K-Supreme.

Winner of Measurement: K-Supreme

Value for Money

With very similar retail and sale prices, the K-Supreme provides better value with its superior performance, wider range of settings, and higher-end finish.

For budget-focused buyers, the K-Elite is the more affordable pick for basic Keurig brewing.

But the K-Supreme justifies its moderately higher cost with more strength, flexibility, and premium design.

Winner of Measurement: K-Supreme

Overall Winner: Keurig K-Supreme

keurig elite vs supreme

Our overall winner is the Keurig K-Supreme. Here’s why:

First, the K-Supreme simply brews better tasting coffee. Or at least that’s what we found.

Its multi-stream technology and adjustable strength settings allow you to customize the flavor and potency of each cup.

In side-by-side tests, the K-Supreme produced a stronger, bolder cup of coffee that you can fine-tune to your preferences.

Second, the design and build quality give the K-Supreme an edge.

Its stainless steel exterior looks sleeker and feels more durable and high-end compared to the plastic construction of the K-Elite.

Though compact, the K-Supreme still offers a large water reservoir with an easy-grip handle.

Finally, the K-Supreme is packed with more features to maximize your coffee experience.

It gives you control over brew size, strength, temperature, and one-touch presets. These advanced but easy-to-use custom settings let you brew the perfect customized cup every time.

In the end, the more adjustable brewing, premium design, and versatile programming of the K-Supreme make it a worthy step up from the more basic K-Elite model.

If you take your coffee seriously and want maximum flavor and functionality, the K-Supreme is the winner of this Keurig showdown. Its performance and abilities simply outshine the decent but less sophisticated K-Elite.

And don’t forget to check out our piece on how to use a Keurig coffee maker.

Our Testing Process

breville barista express vs pro

Our review process follows the same basic steps for each of our coffee reviews.

These steps are:

  • Extensive research online
  • Reading through user reviews
  • Check competing products
  • Check expert opinions
  • Personal testing

Check out how we review our products.

Conclusion

So that’s it!

You now have everything you need to make an informed decision.

Like we said above, our top pick is the K-Supreme.

But we understand that everyone is different and some people reading this might prefer the K-Elite. So we’ve provided links to both.

Click the buttons below to buy either the K-Elite or K-Supreme on Amazon.

And don’t forget… a coffee machine like a Keurig is just one way to make coffee. Check out our article on how to use a French press or how to make cold brew at home.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for another Keurig coffee maker that’s still great value for money, check out our comparison review of the Keurig Duo vs Duo Plus.

FAQ

Which is better Keurig K-Elite or Keurig K Supreme?

The Keurig K-Supreme is better overall based on its stronger coffee flavor, more premium design, and greater number of customizable features.

What is the difference between the Keurig Supreme and Supreme Plus?

The standard K-Supreme is the base model with four brew sizes and an over-ice brew mode. The K-Supreme Plus has a fifth brew size, temperature control and a larger water reservoir.

Is Keurig Supreme worth it?

Yes, the Keurig Supreme is worth the slightly higher investment compared to the K-Elite due to its better performance, aesthetics, adjustability, and value. The more versatile brewing and programming make it worthwhile for coffee enthusiasts.

Which Keurig is the most popular?

The Keurig K-Mini is a highly favored model among Keurig’s lineup. It boasts a slim profile at just five inches in width, making it a perfect fit for any space. It also offers the versatility to brew coffee in two distinct cup sizes. Check out our review here.

Photo of author

AUTHOR

My name is Colm O’Regan. I’m a self-confessed coffee nut who probably drinks a little too much of the stuff every morning. And I founded Moderno Coffee with the goal of providing the best coffee guides and reviews on the web.